Page images



who had manifested a different sentiment, by exclaiming:

"When I shall be found, sir, in my place here in the Senate or elsewhere, to sneer at public merit because it happened to spring up beyond the little limits of my own State or neighborhood; when I refuse, for any such cause, or for any cause, the homage due to American talent, to elevated patriotism, to sincere devotion to liberty and the country—if I see extraordinary capacity and virtue in any son of the South—and if, moved by local prejudice, or gangrened by State jealousy, I get up here to abate the tithe of a hair from his just character and fame, may my tongue cleave to the roof of my mouth."

How deep the emotion in the speech of the Irishman Emmett, when about to receive his sentence of death for what was called treason!

"I have but a few words more to say. I am going to my cold and silent grave; my lamp of life is nearly extinguished; my race is run; the grave opens to receive me, and I sink into its bosom. I have but one request to make at my departure from this world: it is the charity of its silence! Let no man write my epitaph; for as no man who knows my motives dare now vindicate them, let not prejudice or ignorance asperse them. Let them and me repose in obscurity and peace, and my tomb remain uninscribed until other times and other men can do justice to my character. When my country takes her place among the nations of the earth, then, and not till then, let my epitaph be written. I am done."

82. Pathos.-What is commonly called Pathos in a speaker or writer is an emotion of pity or deep interest awakened by the suffering of others, generally associated with a respect for their moral character, and perhaps a love of them for some extraordinary excellence. It is a sympathetic pain, not wholly without pleasure. Washington Irving's description of the death of the wife of Emmett on account of her grief, and his description of the burial of a mother, are full of pathos. Dickens's description of the death of Little

Nell, in the "Old Curiosity Shop," is deeply touching. Pathos is a great element of power in the pulpit.

It might be supposed that inasmuch as the passion must exist before it can be expressed, and that if it exists it will naturally clothe itself in appropriate language, no rules of Rhetoric will compass it or help the orator. But if its power is known, and the best examples of its expression are studied, its appropriate expression will become more natural and easy.

83. A common Fault. The great fault of many writers is an attempt to express pathos that they do not feel, and particularly to overload their productions with empty declamation about passion, instead of encouraging the true feeling where it should exist, and expressing it in simple language. In such a case the speaker defeats his own purpose, and excites only disgust.

[blocks in formation]


84. Definition, and Illustrations.-TASTE is the sus-" ceptibility to pleasure from works of art.

The pleasure, however, which is awakened by the utility of a work, is not primarily attributed to the Taste, but particularly the gratification arising from its beauty, or from the qualities which seem designed primarily to please. A house may be strong, durable, in a healthy locality, convenient, and therefore please our judgment on account of its utility; but it may be at the same time ill-shapen, of a disagreeable color, and so placed, with reference to the streets and the Iocalities around, as to offend our sense of the fitness of things. In such a case we say that, though useful, it is built in poor taste.

A written production or speech ought to please us if it accomplishes its end, and so it does in that respect; but if, in addition to accomplishing its main purposewhatever that may be-it pleases us by its beauty, appropriateness, and conformity to what we think is fitting and proper, it is peculiarly commendable.

Nor is that all: whatever exhibits good taste is thereby so much the more likely to receive attention, and to exert its full force, perhaps indeed more than it

deserves for its intrinsic merit. Beauty is desirable in itself, for its own power to please.

85. Essential Beauty in Composition.—There is undoubtedly essential beauty in well-chosen language, well-constructed sentences, well-arranged arguments, a due admixture of plain and figurative expressions, a proper structure of the entire composition. A good taste recognizes genuine beauty, and also is displeased at its absence, and pained at deformity.

86. Is there any Standard of Taste?-The standard of Taste is inflexible, so far as it regards intrinsic beauty alone, but the mind is influenced by education, so that persons in one age may approve what is disapproved in another age. A nation may have a peculiar standard of Taste on some matters, and to a certain extent. French writers, for instance, usually break up their pages into many paragraphs, and write in a sharp, pointed style; German writers, on the average, make longer paragraphs. This is a mere national fashion, to which there are many exceptions, and in both cases it may prove temporary.

There are so many varieties of beauty, esteemed so variously by different persons, and there are so many artificial or cultivated preferences, that it is a recognized truth that disputes on matters of taste can not be absolutely settled.

87. Criticism. Criticism is the subjecting of the writings and speeches of others to examination according to the rules of Rhetoric and Taste, and the assigning of reasons for their approval or disapproval. It is a healthful practice when not indulged in excess

[blocks in formation]

ively, but a man may be so superfluously critical of others as to intimidate himself. As a matter of fact, the severest critics are often feeble performers. It is easier to destroy, or to find fault with, than to build.

88. How Criticism should be practiced. In the criticism of a production, we should first ascertain its object, and approve or disapprove that according to our judgment. We should next consider its general drift of character, its strength or feebleness, and whether or not it has attained its purpose. Then it may be examined with reference to its general appropriateness of style of thought, of language, of illustration, of adaptation and, in fact, with reference to any actual or desirable quality. Honest criticisms are valuable, and to criticise exhaustively is a rare art.

89. The Cultivation of. Taste.- Taste may be cultivated by familiarity with productions that have borne the test of examination, and are generally approved, by reading critical writings, by making criticisms, and by rigid adherence to rules in our own productions.

90. An Example of Criticism.-Would it not encumber this book too largely, some specimens of long productions would here be inserted and criticised, but perhaps space may be saved by selecting some book with which all are familiar. Take, then, the Book of Job in the Bible, and examine it simply as a literary document.

What is its object? Evidently to present the life and character of Job.

But why present his life? Evidently because it was very extraordinary, illustrating most signally the

« PreviousContinue »